X0MR 
 
 2 0 1 1 t^1 gW
TvW^?e^D}T~ 1uKN[ F r e e d o m   H o u s e 	[R|vhNLuTW1u^1XJTvQjLp
0Z
k;N
\l;Nvc0b0T h e   A u t h o r i t a r i a n   C h a l l e n g e   t o   D e m o c r a c y 	[fOcQ hQt1u^(W2 0 1 0 t^p#~,{Nt^P _N/frgяVASt^O#~p  gENvBfg01uW[f r e e   c o u n t r i e s 	x	_l;NW[e l e c t o r a l   d e m o c r a c i e s 	vxevc~n\-NqgS^W[v1uz^_NhQb`Svu-N 0vQ-Nx	_l;NW[vxev_2 0 0 5 t^v1 2 3 PMp2 0 1 0 t^v1 1 5 PN/f1 9 9 5 t^NOv gNOxev01uW[vxevGR_2 0 0 9 t^v8 9 PMp8 7 P0;1 	
 
 
 
 6q1\(W'Y[
\ehQtl;NSvp bc`wlvTBfl`0RS^-Nqgvl;NSKR{S(W'Y[l	ggKNNYkpY|0WU\z<\eWSi}T]}RekbR]g)RkNhsq}lb0)RkN]}W?e4 2 t^v7_NaS.}ueQWW[weQgQ0bbRvqS_j_NRb0R^0Nyr%Rc_1 9 8 9 t^mQV)Y[NN-Nq}lXl>wv}Wp]SNPvuBfv-NWX#jXbR:cNll;NSjmnovXR0
 
 
 
 1\(Wg-NW'Yx֖_N	g
N\}l|vw@b -NW	i}T FO(W-NWvu@\hQR25XXKNN<ONNN~*g*gb>ev2bR'`NNs^o`NO06qvu2 0   N }+ggNOoCn6mgnv ,{	Nl T h e   T h i r d   W a v e 	l;NSjmno]я>\rBf'Y[vvIQIƖ-N(W>wYv
Oe-Ye?b/OW[T^'Yv-NW'Yx/f&TS2L,{Vlvl;NSKRD i a m o n d 2 0 0 0 1 3 - 3 3 K a r a t n y c k y 2 0 0 2 9 9 - 1 1 2 	0
 
 
 
 vQ-N-NWv 'YWcw UpbR0WP}Tǌ,g;NZ
kq}lvOP[H a e r p f e r   e t   a l . 2 0 0 9 3 6 9 	FOvQ/f&T_URl;NSfS0RNNnfMvܕ;0x[PckRR_T.z҉^xvz-NW'YxNMQ͑Hvut^ qglNN vM0;2 	F{wgܕ_cpvl;NS}W-NW'Yx*gOl;NSvS,gedNl;NSt֊vQjORg-NW*gOSvl;NSw0,geqQRpVRHQ!|Nl;NSxvzvT.z_NSH u n t i n g t o n @bcQvl;NSSVe_cWNH u n t i n g t o n @bcQvl;NS!j_\Op[_ g_Rg-NW*gOl;NSMRofS_0
 
 
 
 N0l;NSxvzvT.z_
 
 l;NSvxvz
\aSb
\Z
kq}lvl;NSz4xBf_j0V }Te_l;NSvR0hNel;N6Rv^-NSl;NVl;NmSI{X|OUL0
\eqQ"u;NW[ ܕ;v&qޞ/fYUO[s1uui
k0Rl;Nvl;NSz4xbIW0X, l;NSvRROiQPd\bYgQui
k\6RW[傁2l;NS1\vQgQRROwXGR/f1u
NN1u?el|vR;NR9eW[v?elԚ6RXGR/f1uN
N1uNl(W!ql_SW[]RJRc6Rv`lNawi}Tc\6R?e
k0
 
 
 
 1 0l;NS_t֊
 
 
 
 (WNSx[Lucl;NSv_t֊ve{s>wYFOvQ-NcQ|q}'`Rgvx[[[SxeP o t t e r G o l d b l a t t K i l o h   a n d   L e w i s vD e m o c r a t i z a t i o n Xf/fcl;NSSVT^f-Nv|O|O0rfcQl;NSv	N.z_( 1 ) sNS_Nhx[pS e y m o u r   M a r t i n   L i p s e t r_7_l;NSbRv }-N>y>yg}obTv }( 2 ) IW_r_7__?elNz-N?elv;NRxdOˑl;NSvSVNhx[pD a n k w a r t   A .   R u s t o w ( 3 ) P}i_dk_@bܕ;v&qޞ(We
kRP}ivwOˑl;NSbR&TNhx[pB r i n g t o n   M o o r e P o t t e r G o l d b l a t t K i l o h   a n d   L e w i s 1 9 9 7 	0
 
 
 
 dkY2 0 0 2 t^M i c h a e l   M c F a u l (WW o r l d   P o l i t i c s g
R@b|vhv T h e   F o u r t h   W a v e   o f   D e m o c r a c y   a n d   D i c t a t o r s h i p :   N o n c o o p e r a t i v e   T r a n s i t i o n s   i n   t h e   P o s t c o m m u n i s t   W o r l d  Xevu-Npˑ_qQ"u;N?e
kwǑ(uV.z
NTvIW_SˑvQIWvSV_?e
kwvT\O_  ( c o o p e r a t i v e   a p p r o a c h e s   t o   r e g i m e   c h a n g e ) IWv^T\O!j_  ( a   n o n c o o p e r a t i v e   m o d e l   o f   t r a n s i t i o n ) _qQ"u;N?e
kwvVg7_( c a u s a l   p a t h s   o f   p o s t c o m m u n i s t   r e g i m e   c h a n g e ) ˑpu8^saLuT eNLu ( e x p l a i n i n g   a n o m a l i e s :   b o r d e r s   a n d   t h e    W e s t  ) vQP}֊p ,{Vl v?e
kw ,{	Nl l;NSgPiQKNvIWNzgTu#IW_@b"uuvԚ6R_N	g@b]pu0
 
 
 
 l;N?elYUO"uuZ
k?eԚSUONIWpl;N?eԚIWv?el0}o>yghNxepUO/fx[S>yܕ;v͑pL0L a r r y   D i a m o n d _ l;NvRR dkXޞ_ gQ(W i n t e r n a l 	 Y(W e x t e r n a l 	iQP_ˑP͑vOUL0D i a m o n d p1 	Z
kԚ6RvR2 	Z
kteԚ}o|vU\vܕ|3 	1uP<Pv4 	lQl>ygvcwI{V }/fl;NIW g͑ gQ(W xeL a r r y   D i a m o n d 2 0 0 8 8 8 - 1 0 6 	0dkY1 	Pd:y{Heg2 	Ts^XR3 	6RvP6RcRvhN4 	l;NvTSR5 	NfkRcRl;NSI{V }p;Nv Y(W xeL a r r y   D i a m o n d 2 0 0 8 1 0 6 - 1 3 5 	0gQ(Wxe7_Z
k?eԚgQ萄v
kRNR0}o|vU\vܕHea0>ygP<Pv>eI{bTW͑ _  6R^gQu'` vRgY(Wxe7_l;NSvdceHea0W{Heg0W>ygvߎ'`lx'`XRW͑v/f [  P}iw vRg0
 
 
 
 2 0N^l;NSvSV!j_
 
 
 
 
NNdN
Nl;NSt֊KNgiKNYW[|vul;NIWv[IRg-NN^v
0,{	Nl0T h e   T h i r d   W a v e D e m o c r a t i z a t i o n   i n   t h e   L a t e   T w e n t i e t h   C e n t u r y 	XfCN/flQxvzl;NSv}xQW\O0,gfmeQRg bl;NSvT.zSVpgTW[vl;NS2zS/f~^PV }vNoiNvP}g0_N1\/fl;NSvSVT
NvTpTl;NSve__Nl	gXԚi(uv!j_  ( H u n t i n g t o n 1 9 9 1 3 8 - 3 9 )   0v{YdkH u n t i n g t o n Nxk
}Q b7 0 t^N8 0 t^N"uu,{	Nll;NSvYV }-NNNRmQV } gp͑  ( H u n t i n g t o n 1 9 9 1 4 6 - 1 0 8 )   
 
 
 
 X	}o|vU\}oqS_j}o|vU\O_NlYe4ln06eeQcGS2O>yg-Nv-N"u}NxeXR0Bl1u>ygv-N"u}_Nbpl;N?e
kvWy09hdH u n t i n g t o n vwlvu}o|vU\0Rvvuvz^MTwg}oqS_jb}o4x"uGRZ
kԚ6R\SIWpl;N?e^0
 
 
 
 N	Tlq}l
kZvp=T?e>~vV@\Z
k?eԚq}l
kZvckvu'`
NFO__Vp?e>~V@\8om0RNlꌑuNN?e
kvTl'`8^SVp_Ov͎N+cWe0}o4x"uiQ!kwlqS_j8om1Y0
 
 
 
 	N	[Yez4Xv9eWeeWcwYe7_PNv
\V?eYeR▄v;N5_NS1YeYe)Y;NYeYeg(WS
\?e^XKR-N__nbo;N҉rvsaH u n t i n g t o n TtGP-WcwYevd5_gO2l;Nv|vU\0
 
 
 
 V	YORRve?eV{YW?e^b_jivLR_N1gq_u/fzl['`0Wq_0RXPW[vl;NS0c KNYWvRReSNk^Rc\6R?e
k_NSN;bkXPW[pTl;NS0
 
 
 
 N	ntHeaW[bR0W2Ll;NS\SgRvQNW[wHe$\0$\vQ/fNgQ?el|vuOULvW[fSg^gP1ul;NSOzlvuNv?elVX0
 
 
 
 mQ	\NvzlV{H u n t i n g t o n pl;N6R^vQs&N
N/f}o|vU\bvQNY(WV }v_P}g/fW[6R[vܕzlV{@b0
N{?elzl[pTl;NSvR_jpUONPN6q/fl;NS g͑vERR0
 
 
 
 dNmQ;NvV }KNYH u n t i n g t o n cWc
NTl;NSNzv^W0Np,{	Nll;NSvNz'YSRp	N.z^WiT r a n s f o r m a t i o n 	0fcR e p l a c e m e n t 	NSyIT r a n s p l a c e m e n t   bR u p t f o r m a 	H u n t i n g t o n 1 9 9 1 1 1 2 	(WdkF{_N!|euRNf
 
 
 
 X	i
 
 
 
 W?e6^-[sl;NBf1\gQsi0iSSRpNRNPkH u n t i n g t o n 1 9 9 1 1 2 7 - 1 4 2 	
 
 
 
 1 	9ei>mvQs(WZ
kԚ6RQsXvOpTl;NSveT/fSSN_6qvb[o(W2bp|v?elwv,{XRϑ0
 
 
 
 2 	
kRvrs_9ei>m_NZ
k{kN0[gfcb/fEZ
kI{e_(We	g?e
k-NS_;N\0WMOYdkMbU\l;NSv]z0
 
 
 
 ( 3 )   1uSv1YWe:   l;NSvNz
N_6q/fX^vS_NgmG0R
NTWԚcQX6Rl;NSvBlum0RSl;NRRvSd0
 
 
 
 ( 4 )   X6RO[>m: rs_
kRO_9ei>m YYl;NSFO{S
NmdO[>mT9ei>mc0bvR0Vdk9ei>mv,{XR8^8^/fn?e^0͎_vq_NSbR[P_jiQN9eiv/ecOSNؚ}[T-NvO[>m0
 
 
 
 ( 5 )   S
\>mT\O: (Wl;NSvNz-N9ei>m_N vQNS
\>m0>ygWԚ2LxFUOiNzfR)R0
 
 
 
 N	fc
 
 
 
 vuS
\>mWԚ6^-[sl;NNZ
k?e
kWbcBfsSQsfc0T#j0Wfc_NSRpNN	NPkH u n t i n g t o n 1 9 9 1 1 4 2 - 1 5 1 	
 
 
 
 ( 1 )   pc?e
k%-r: 1ue?e
kgQ萄v9ei>m*Y1_\b9h,g
NX[(WVdkS
\>m_P}TvQNSbe	gZ
k?e
kvWԚD}T~b_bN?e^gQKNO[>m2LbavXRRN[cO[>m?e^vt`0
 
 
 
 ( 2 )   ?e
kvW: vuS
\>mvRRe8o7_'YOS2LcZ
k?e^vLR0NLRS/fN͎N?eb/fN\N[gcsbwܞLRO[0
 
 
 
 ( 3 )   W_v%-r: (WZ
k?e^W_9ei>m_v_ZP}YnPkX܈vuBfQsv
kRwzz&NMzui\BlvQNW[v/ecN^z]vTl'`06qVp9ei>mgQSQs҉Tl'`vb-r6q_N NTSFUOS0
 
 
 
 	N	yI
 
 
 
 Vp?e^S
\>mWԚǑSoTLR bl;NSv[sBfsSQsyI0(WyINz-N֖6q?e^Xa1\?e
kvfS2LxFUFO/f__/fR0WS
\>m-N/ecl;NvnT>m"uuNR0(WdkNRNz-N?e^TS
\>m-Nv;N\WԚbl	gNUOXe YGrbzl[W[*gOvԚ6RpT/f NTSFUve_OTbyI_vl;NSH u n t i n g t o n 1 9 9 1 1 5 1 - 1 6 3 	0
 
 
 
 N(WP}֊-Nyr%RcQ }o|vU\O_l;NbpS?el\O_l;Nbpw[0
\*gOvl;NW[O*gOv?el gNOP_vOl;NԚ6R
\NP>yg0
\NP]O/fX.z g}Yv?eԚ0NPT#j_wQPؚfvKblO[bl;NvIWe2`o2>m_N2`O[>mNNgSMQ0WX[(WW0 H u n t i n g t o n 1 9 9 1 3 1 6 	
 
 
 
 	N0N^t֊Rg-NWl;NSvQj
 
 
N֊/fgQ(WbY(Wvl;NRR<ONNN!qldR-NW\6RZ
kԚ6Ru(Wяt^O-NWZ
kԚ6R
NFO
Np ufo:yvQiz[|vU\vyrrA n d r e w   N a t h a n   ( 2 0 0 3 )   cQ̗'`Z
kԚ6R  ( r e s i l i e n t   a u t h o r i t a r i a n i s m )   vi_	g%ReZ
kԚ6Rv1_yr-NqQP1u?el|~bv{S08^SP6R>m|?el0?elԚ6RvRk\miS0^6RS?elST?el8eQI{6R^S__Nc~W[
\e>yg}oWvc6RRMQl;NIWv0RO0gsO_e	Q(W
0 Svui
k;N-NW*gO|vU\0Xe-Np(W2 0 0 2 t^-NqQS,{ASmQF\hQWNh'Yg_-NWvW[Ԛ6R]IWpui
kZ
kԚ6RvmTԚ&N\KN1zp  Svui
k;N ( d e g e n e r a t i v e   t o t a l i t a r i a n i s m ) 0[(WD}T~
NNO	gui
k;Nv͑,gFO(WK\O
N{SHTsQvvuYZ
k;Nvri_0<P_;av/f!q֊_obqgPkqQ"u?e
kvo}W^<Ov Sui
k;N&N!q|v8o20Wl;NIWbRvHhO  ( gsO0_e	Q2 0 0 3 1 7 - 1 9 )   0
 
 
 
 1 0-NWvl;NS % %/f&TS_1uSY
 
 
 
 -NWYUOpTl;NSbTx[P(Wxvzl;NSBf'Y
NvgHQ@S%R1uSl i b e r a l i z a t i o n 	l;NSd e m o c r a t i z a t i o n 	v
NT0
 
 
 
 x[SXoA l f r e d   S t e p a n 	e1 9 8 8 t^cQnZivf&NNe1 9 9 6 t^g2J u a n   J .   L i n z 	(WX,gcl;NIWVOULv
TW-N͑3uT#jvޞ1uS/fc^l;N?eԚv_j6RKNNS4OXN?eV{>ygwOYk\vZԚjg	gBfPf}N;N'`R]KR'Yvzz_NXNYNOwNvPN2[ˑ>e'YYxev?elr>eVO_N19e2@b_RMvcef͑v/f[_?elS
\0l;NS 4OW1uSFOf^l_NfwQ	gyr%R0W?eli_0l;NS lQz-rv
k)RN_c6R?e^_N 1uz-rvx	]zl[q}l0O(u#jv[_fo0W	gS	g1uSFOl	gl;NSS t e p a n 1 9 8 8 6 L i n z   a n d   S t e p a n 1 9 9 6 3 	0
 
 
 
 mg^(W
0,{	Nl
0Xf-NGRcQYg(unfxve_xQ gؚzlV{/fl;N?elv|Ӛl;NSNzvܕu1\/f(u1u0lQTlQs^vx	-N"uuv?e^OSNN
N/fN.zel"uuv?e^0
NNx	KNMRTx	KN_vtePl;NSNz8^ASR_ܖNfeBf8^}rm0R^l;N?e
kvB}P}0l;N?e
kv{v6q_/fl;NԚ6RvV0vkKNN1uSS/fZ
k?eԚv@\萋>e.z>el	g}1u1uz-rvx	Oxd?e^\N0ck(WU\1uSvZ
k?eԚ8^gˑ>e?elr0>egN֊Lf}l>w֊0>e~ge^jg0>eXNNOd\vlQw	Lx	0AQ1lQl>ygvg.z_NS_Wl;NSveTǑSvQNek_FO
Nbؚd\vzlV{NNx	OWH u n t i n g t o n 1 9 9 1 9 	0
 
 
 
 1uSl;NS/fiQPvܕ0FO{SoW
NTvi_M o n s h i p o u r i 1 9 9 5 1 2 	0b|vsx[hZgS c o t t   M a i n w a i r i n g 	(uiQS!|UnZivq@SR1uSl;NSvi_0N?el1uScmv/f(WZ
kԚ6RgQX6Rv}lQl1uvd5_l;NScmv/fITl;N?elvKRNsSIT
NTv?elԚ6RM a i n w a i r i n g 1 9 9 2 2 9 8 	0
 
 
 
 
\ecR-NWl;NSKRO1uSS*QHQel;NS0Vp傒l	g}N1uSv~g}lNUO}
kKRblQl>ygvD}T~;mRv_[fS0R?e^vSbX0FO
\eZ
k\6Rvq}lONUO1uScev~g}_6q_X6RNl
\e2Xekl;NSv4Bl;N5_01\dkKNYH u n t i n g t o n @b  }o|vU\O_l;NbpS?el\O_l;Nbpw[ (W-NWvuMRv̀ofN?elvxdfo_ܕu0;3 	
 
 
 
 -NWv?eltXYs)Yb(WvQW\O
0'YIW-NWl;NS0beuxvzFhg0-N@bc0Rv >m|;N f a c t i o n a l i s m 	/fPvvu͑v҉l;NIWvMRc/fq}lvR0.za
NvR&N
N/fe8^v)RvKN-rbNOd\!k?eV{Rgk/fܕe/f&T2L?el>e0/f&T}cZ
kq}lvRgk
NPq}lƖWgQ萁RSQnT>m09ei>mNivRϑ`Sdv
\e7_lx>mv*QRR	giQ.zb__sS?elzlV{d\vRb͎?el\NvR[PeSUhs0_NSTBf|vu0;4 	
 
 
 
 asTW-NW'Yxl;NSvMRc  ?el
Nv9ei>e1uS	 ?el9ei>m_N1\/fnT>mv\FO-NWvؚd\(W?el
NvO['`vvuؚX,Ǌ0Rv9eiO[>mcqKNRRO
/fN/ecb/fS
\9ePSvR}oԚ6RT[L
\Y>e ~^NN SN?el
Nv9ei>m&N
NX[(W0Vg-NWf}@bZPv?el9ei@b;N5_vvQ[W,g/fL?e9eiOYy^t^S0f}0WeOmiR
kI{0;5 	
 
 
 
 2 0N^l;NS!j_vQj
 
 
 
 9hdMR傝OH u n t i n g t o n vl;NS!j_OjWGRN?el\O[sl;NSv i!j_ <ONN gp&{T-NW?elؚd\vRT0SS`?el
NvnT9ei>mfXs\hMRof*Xa0vuMRv-NW?elؚd\
NFO
N;NR2L?el1uSv9eiSVp
\ SQs v>yg
Niz[ؚ^}5_R'Y?e
k}izvc6RR^0
 
 
 
 Od-NW?e萄vxed2 0 1 0 t^-NWvlQqQ[hQ}
N2oN1 5 . 6 % p5 4 9 0 QNlc^02 0 1 0 t^-NWvW2/e2oE^/f7 . 8 % p5 3 3 4 QNlc^0?e萄v1XJT2 0 1 0 t^vWgQlQqQ[hQ}N{6 . 7 % _N1\/fYN3 4 6 QNlc^0?elQ^v2 0 1 1 t^{xed-NlQqQ[hQ{/ep6 2 4 0 QNlc^N{p6 0 2 0 QNlc^vW2/e}iz}kBvOeP0YNTRvcw	Nev{R(WXwv=~Tؚ0;6 	
 
 
 
 VdkF{[-NW'Yx>ygvrl1\PXPl0v'YXRKX#jψbBf(WQlFOVpKP[*Y'YVdkXBfKN_\K˄c0FOYg-NWZ
kq}lXvǑ(uVSbve_O
\_NUO}
kKR1\P/fnqlXP'YXRKFO{S
N[Q#lcYqX#jw
NwUOBfg"uu'Yrpzl#jqS`Xvel/U	gg_-NW?elؚd\͑eQs nT>m O2L1uSv9ei>e0
 
 
 
 V0-NW*gOl;NSvMRof
 
 meQ -NWb
\vOUL(We}o>ygP}iw
\?e
k@b bvld0NOUL;Nvhsb__p>yg
NlQs^ŏd'Y2_|v>ygd\KNv
\zlzOYNSW[@bc6Rv}o>ygǌnsNSd	g?e}ǌ,gvgQؚy^0*YP[@bD}b
kǌ,g@bXePvOUL]}bp-NWl>w7_pv>yg]RjYaOnBib-NW>ygSb7Rv[o(WRϑ0}o|vU\@b bv>ygwv]}bp-NWgQ萄vqS_jxef
\-NqQ?e
k bN]'YvldNgImo2 0 1 1 9 5 	0
 
 
 
 
NN(W[evD}T~0L?e?elvccN-NWv>ygWԚlQl>yg k:-NW?e^bavhNWy0QpNMQ>wvl(`N}"uu/SƖ2N#Hegvu@\f^gN[e@b^iv?eTS0O*
N*6R^\MRHeagQ(W[e@bc6Rv{
W0TBfK(uZ
k?eԚ@bX[(WW[XRBL
\>ygWԚ0>ygSbRR}}vvcnNgImo2 0 1 1 9 6 	0
 
 
 
 Y
N@b1ueS0R?e^vX6RNN
Ne_2Lv}
kKRSN_|vU\vQS4Ovl;N9ei6q_N!q_Ǌw0
NNve?elؚd\xdNX돹e_;dNUO	gܕl;N9eiKRv2L#jMRfm0p`v[_NX[(WWX.zpjvKa^YNgQ@bcQOvޞ
 
 
 
 1 	>ygv|vU\TX'Y/f
NS;dv
 
 
 
 W-NWv}o|vU\-NWv>yg_N8obw>ygv1u^]}zzMRcؚBl>yg1uv|Tr(W|~~Xw0.zBl\g\-NW>yg2XekvN
k|vU\\􁊍OYvNBlN	g
\Vv0s^I{veP[0.zBl\gO>ygSTMRp
NTV _N1\/f>ygv1u\2Xekd'YNlv
\V\g_0R2Xek
\le1\/f-NWl;N|vU\vWy0(W#jv|vU\`lNl	gNXaQV0R\6R;NKN-NsSOl;NP \6R;NQs_N
Ng_0R-NW'Y>wvcST
\͑0.zl;N|vU\vgQ(WRRx[/f
NS;dv0
 
 
 
 2 	NS
 
 
 
 NS/fXP
NS;dv>ygS/f>yg|vU\v6q__N
NS;dPS0NS
NPmS0R-NW\NT-NW\d\vSf;Nv/fmS0R-NW>ygteԚvS0vMR-NWt^XNvNNPl	gԚgN\6R;NNPu;m(Wp1u0[ՈT>ev>yg-NNP`v/ffYv1uT[NPvYe_N
NSgT\6R;NSgT1uTl;N0Vdk_|vU\v<wIQOwNS\gO_-NWs(WXNt^NbNXNNfPTe1uTl;N`9eNPONPT\6RP``_0^z(W#jvsN>ygNvWy
Nv?elԚ6R
NS/f\6R;Nv0v{-NWl;Nv|vU\1uewkS0?elTeSvSV
NgX^g	g_'Yvfb_Ng	gP /fSN`0RvFO/f_MRofOpTl;N/f_6qvN_N
Ng*YEN0NgQ2 0 0 8 2 8 4 	
 
 
 
 NjvKa^[-NWd^teԚ|vU\\Pn
NMR&TGR_\ΏOl;N
NNpUON-NW?e^ؚd\N
 YbR0WX6RNUO}
kKRvQ-NXP͑SVS/f-NW'Y>wv_-N
\evQ@bg_Blvdk l;N ^|_ l;N 09hdN2mRKagA s i a n   B a r o m e t e r   S u r v e y A B S 	(W2 0 0 3 t^vǌe-No:y	g8 2 % v-NWNpNPvMRv?elԚ6Rpl;N_N	g7 9 % v-NWNh:ynavMRvl;NsrSH a e r p f e r   e t   a l . 2 0 0 9 3 7 1 	0FO_ 1uKN[ v1XJT-NSw-NW_2 0 0 3 t^NO
/f1u^s^GWp6 . 5 v
N1uW[0c KN-NWvl>wYxenesr&Np1\/fNP@bBlvl;N_N1\/f@bvl;Nx	0l;NzlV{0l;N{tl;Nvcw	^1u;N_l;Nl i b e r a l   d e m o c r a c y 	N}w1uN
kpOxkvl;N!j_0
 
 
 
 Q9hds)YbvRg-NWv\6R?e
k[
N]}|vU\0RNXPek_N1\/fT+PkN'Yx[Yec0W
T-NWOUL\[Ξ[SA n d r e w   J .   N a t h a n 	@bv[bN	g̗'`vZ
k?eԚr e s i l i e n t   a u t h o r i t a r i a n i s m 	0;N_ve'\s^_8 0 t^NRY!P\0cRvؚd\NN6R^9ei0 g͑vvu6q/f
kR|~bv6R^S0\N O6R^^zNwO02 0 0 2 t^_lol&o0,{	NN,{VN\NKNvNc/f
kR|~b6R^Svj0 |~bOULv
Nx[0gQ萾|?elv
Niz['` gOZ
k?eԚ (WgQRNz-NpWeb IW  Ξ[S2 0 0 7 4 3 	 O6R^GRO |vR?eb2L?el%-rNV{R?evVT_jgn g\ Ξ[S2 0 0 7 5 3 	0;7 	
 
 
 
 F{p
kR|~bv6R^S O6R^	dN?el\d\RvSn\KNY_NT#jR7_N\d\}ws	gԚ6Rvzl_0|V	go}YveQ 4X_j6RSNxOꁫv[qS)Rv6qgX7_vQ}izvR^fR
NzYOR0WX6RlBl1ul;Nvr0OYZԚ}ybv|vT֖6qS/fQZlQlRϑv	gHe_FO_NSSNO?e^@b)R(u0P/fNgQc0R(W-NWvNo}I n t e r n e t 	/fXP
vs^,g/fR7_NPNAmTnvs^0/fXP]wQSN(u0-NW?e^SN)R(uNo}O[P?e^v_TaWvu6q-NW>yg_NSN)R(uNo}OcR1ul
kKRv|vU\0?e^T>yg(WNo}WU\NXPc6RTSc6Rv%-r0;8 	ckYD i a m o n d @b 
N{YUOybS/fX.z]wQ(u[O[sؚvvj`vvv01\P^dTSN/fǌ
YCQ;NTt'`֊v]wQ[P_NS(uerqvRT[eW[c6Rvui
k?e
k8`S0Z
kW[_NSN8`Sǌ
ObST0R^<OvHeg0 D i a m o n d 2 0 1 0 7 1 	;9 	
 
 
 
 teԚ -NWl;NSvMRof
N[hQ`FOsSONjvKa^ORg_N -NW?e^\d\XaMzuick>yg'Y>wvBl^xdNX6Rve_Ob
\0
 
 
 
 N0P}֊
 
 6qe6q-NWqQ"uq}l
NXa;NR9eiVdk'Y[g_vi!j_]aOa
NS|vu(Wdk`lKNN9ei>mvW?enT>mvS
\>mT\Ol;NSe_\SpyI!j_=~/fkfc!j_fRizeP0Ts^0(WyI!j_-N?e^v\ؚd\Y/fnboWRvTSFU҉rb_b#jvhNOYc?el\d\KNY	vQY_j/fvvu͑v0
 
 
 
 VdkF{p-NW'Yxl;NSvS_SzleNNV
 
 
 
 1 . [hNp}o|vU\|vut8$\vQ/fwg\Pnbw0
 
 
 
 2 . ;NNGR [q}l}/f&T"uuR$\vQ/f7_	gRvnT9ei>m/f&TQs0
 
 
 
 3 . QMTNlK(uNASXN }eWfkhV  }Kb_jvO(u0
 
 
 
 4 . (WhQt'`#lPwtXuKaqS_jKNN-NW'Yxz6q|vu'Y}p&N"uu'YϑvuKal0
 
 
 
 dN,{NޞO
g_-NWv?elؚd\QsnT9ei>mvQsKNYvQYO	Nޞv_	gS-NWvuMR?e^\XabpRvTSFU0OY֖6qL i n d a   C o o k 1 9 9 3 	fN>yg	gS(W?eԚ YcO1\mi0Ye0OO?bI{cey)RBf>ehgN?elPN
k)R0FOvu}owg\PnbwBf?e^1ue!ql|~~e\LHQMRvbdkBf1\	gSQsS
\vWԚO_?e^_vQTSFUOzlvuMRv@\b0
 
 
 
 }ovld?e
kv
Niz[KNvܕ|/fofvFO_N
N_euv/f}a}ZԚYF a c e b o o k TT w i t t e r 	2Noi}Tq`vRϑK e n n y 2 0 1 1 3 1 	0}Kb_jvRϑof}֊X0ZS[sSBf
o`/f-NWяO};mR|vU\v͑ޞvQ-N$\NsSBfP
vH_'`ؚbw$\p_vQq_/fP}TbPq}vNܕ|d'YNN_v{
WS'`O_Nܕ|}a}S0c KN}}bp-NWNPnNRves^_NbpNP
o`NRv{SKjhfbp2L?el>ygS?elRTvZNNgImo2 0 1 1 9 5 - 9 6 	0XeaXQZl>wRTwOS
\WԚ1\	g Yvǌ,g Y?e^\2LTSFU0֖6q}_NS/f\6R?e^c6RNlv]wQFOlQl_NSN9e2&NU(uN]wQS0RTNX[vz^NP1\SNdWeZ
k;ND i a m o n d 2 0 1 0 7 1 	0
 
 
 
 tXltvpLXT/fяt^OWܕ;v&qޞKNX$\vQwk}Ne,g3 1 1 'Y0W@b6^Ov8h}pNEe8h[hQYlgSQ^bp'Y[wvvqL0(W-NWHQMR	gV|v@b6^OvWX0WN4lYlgYN'Yϑ^v8h^SVe,gNEeS0Rܕ;0֖6qNt^-NW__[^N8hvܕve[h:y\f\P[8h@b	geNv8h^3uˊHhhQbjg@b	g^-Nv8h^
N&{[hQjnz;R\P]&Nte-Nwg8hR0FOR-NW\[SYǌ8RFUp[eS/ffBf\Pbk[8h\Omi-NW|vU\8h|vvwgeT&N*g9e0vMRhQt(W^v8hzXqQ	g5 6 PvQ-NN2mW[(W^v	g3 7 P-NW1\`SN2 1 P0;1 0 	
 
 
 
 Yg^<Oe,gv8h[NEeXe|vuN-NWvrl SgfV͑F\Bf"uuv'YϑlPƖԚ
\?e^"uu
Nn#jvS
\WԚ!qu\g/fXvvu'YvRϑO?e^vQTSFU0;1 1 	
 
 
 
 ckYN^wkS
N|vuNvi}T8^8^!qlwX#jN
N	NvqQTޞ/fVp
NSgvNN"uuN?e
kTl'`
NvqS_j&NNd	g Y'YvERRO_?e^v\ؚd\Xa2LTSFU0
NNF{yr%RcQ?el
NvnT9ei>m֖6q&Nl	gOY萄vO2RN
/f<P_gvvVp(W?el\S
\WԚvTSFU-NYg	gnT9ei>m(WvQ-N\O(uNz\SNfpTs^f0
 
 
 
 YH u n t i n g t o n @b  ?el\O_l;Nbpw[ 
N֊/fHQMR@bg_vi!j_b/fc֊pt`vyI!j_-NW?e^v?el\d\/fܕu'`vV }0Yg-NWv?elؚd\-NnT9eiv >m| !qlQbz_N^gSNQsOPTnT9eiv?elPNxdN)RgvTSFUBf_jQsBf Y|vcPSv\O(uyI!j_SNo}Y0WK\O0