˂ҼĿǂˌƐǷǵД࣬҂Ҫ@ӵ^֮⣬ͬr_cߵPϵҲǂWҷ DelhayfģָҼNҼЩ˷֪RKڴxϳɞ顰֪ģconscienceҼ~ǏconscientiaҼ~ԭ˼c֮gĬ֪Rc˵ϵ䌍Ѱڡġ˼YˣĲֻҼNֱXлwҸҼN춵֪Rģᘌw;Č`ДО顣

c˵Pϵб綨fͳɞОġªĂyԹ⣬cҼĹͬЄӄtʹεĂ¸ǰ|µҼλܾ@fʮϽ֣҂ץMYҼقϽ֣҂þſ£ҼǧϽ֣҂ɢҼfϽ֣҂վǰMĵ·ϣʮfϽ֣҂Ҽ߅ҼfϽ֣҂

˵֪Ӱ푣KɂҼRĻoģҲc˵Ľ@FġˣW_ MϣVischerڡcơfĵı|ҼNcVϵֻ҂cĽЮa˵Ҳ҂׌@ӵڬFЫ@ĳNmȻδҪe˶ͬ⣬s׌e˶⡣κΌĻrֵ^ӑՓҲˣδ׌x߶ͬ⣬ڃݺͱϱMҪ׌⣬ӑՓǏĮ¬F͂팍`ۣҲĲʧȮxĆ}

ɵ

ĵărֵֻҼN֪RܳɞЄӡЄĵı_ҲĵĻSBܱ_ģ˱uu׃Û]ġеĭhYı͵˲܉SĠBScƐǷP飬ҹҲܣBhՓһе韩ԶҼԣʧȥ˱˴˵ĵϵԊ˱_ DͣPaul LaurenceDunbarҼ׽СcûڡConscience and RemorseСԊYQ@顰cĵe

ҊҌf
ҊҊ
˦_֣
D^ҵĘ
˂
Ĵٲ؁

ȻҼҵ
ߵ·
ҴС؁ɣģ
ҿҊ
ǣĿ޵Ҳܣ
ҵǻںޡ

xPĂ˵ģ֪ںޣַQʹԻڣַQİlFɁѾãҲѲXāKֻ܂Ɛ֧䡣ڡՓġYfĿʹ҂֑֣Ҳʹ҂ԶţҸf·Ͻ^SUʼKyҌԼD˽⣬ԼӋ󡣡@λˇdrڵx˿ģƺԱ_ͬǣ@ƪՓĵĶЌıȻʾɣ@c_ĝMMƺͬ

Ǐġ̡ÁĵģJ飬l̵ǵǞ˴ݚģǞ˿Cġǣڽ^r£Ľ@ӵĿ򞡣fl̵ģՓAǽ뷨ϵģ錦ˣƺÿ̿ʹܛfe`Ȼo˄tӈԏη̡fڵģ@kM˲_ԺΣU˞˶^y̵ʹ࣬ʲԒfʲ²

Դ˿_܉ԳģKc֮ҼµĂО飬RĿ߀ᚈ̡cīđЊZȡīIm^cϱ𠎣sȻ]ЏUūƶȣ_˸еŭXòİõԹ{ķʽ֧@ӵࡣ춾ܽ^{PM˱Oz߀ãǂOzǼ{⼯РIҲǹȺuA߅ϣYֻҼͱ˳mȻ_˷QힵġǱcivil disobedienceδƶ¶еͨĹ_ҼxߣPµǂ ԼĹMˣhx˵ҕcⷰPϵxrxȺӣBw㣬ں߅N

죬ʹ߀_ǘӓЂĵˣҲǷǳҊġ@ӵĂwĲH]пҊĹxҌHǘOyԾSֵġ죬҂ӑՓĆ}ҪǏhֻǿȥJRĵĴͲ_hȰWоʾƶġ龳situationҲĻuʾĬFȮxȮx龳Įa^ּӏ龳˷֪ͣס

v20oOyΌԺĵĴݚҲҊC@Ny´Ҏģò˼DγɺОƶأFWġ龳о@˼ĳɹĴ˹̹ נķġķġͷաͶġ˹̹Oz򞡱ͶڡǿƣF߀ֻՄѡָTʹʹɃɂֺɣҼ˵ҼЩԭҼքtضġء@ɂֵPϵǿǂ˻wxЄ⵽Ɖĵ^̣ƉǿƁ׃Ť˵ĲXәC顢J֪ɴ˶О顣

˵ġԭָҼЩԳɞĻW͌оѽؽʾ˵S혏ġfʧ{ܡС֑֡ЧJͬȿܱءǣښvʷϣ@ЩҼֱͬأHHKֽܳښvʷضṛlضΡhеĴҎģFϣضƶµġءԳɞҪԭ@ЩܘOظ׃˵˼О飬ʹҼ㲻ҲĸĕrԭŮҼЩƽrooŮЌW@ӴУLš

Ӱ푘OذęI䡢߉RΑBеĹwĥTlķԺ¡O˵{T@ЩؿԽY׺M_͑Zá@NYl\ӏЄӆT񱊵ĕr򡣽M{@ЩⲿصıҪֶΣ߽YҲܳɹؿ˵˼룬T˷ʹĸȥĥ͚ĔˣK׌ϴXĳɆT֪ƣعؕIԼĽX@ЩǞҼIʹҼЧķǏݔĳN֪R׌Ľ@ӵ֪RȻc֮ҼµЄӡ

˂cϵҼ𣬶@֮gļ~ǵ֪R^֪u¡֪u¡fı@ͱҼN£ϣDĵareteҼ~ƺcPϣD־AresKڞ¶xrfҪ֮Ҽf£Ҳ֪R@ĵՓĿѵ¡֪RҼNoɵķeOأ֪Ǻõģʹ֪вҼҲeľʣ֪Ć}ǣͶ龳ՓJ飬֪ȲֹܷİlҲoħħҼNаǲ֪ǡǡǡ֪ʷˣͶfа漰ŰȱԡаǡoߵĿО飬ʹÙϵyĄS@Kȡ档֮Ҳǡ֪ʷ

龳вͬıFʽmȻҪԭʼ⣬Еrܽ^Ҫ⡣ͬӣҪ⣬ܽ^tҪ⣬˂@ɷNⶼQģ@ɷNձʧĕr׃Ҽ]ĵĵطµǣ˂_ʼӑՓĆ}Ƿ߀κάFx˂ϵЛ]Сġ@|ˏđD׃񶨺;ܽ^ĵĕrȮx

ȮxvʷcF

Ȯ֮ܿ˿͸׵飬^ļ󣬌֮IVS̡Óסס򈲻ZԷQǲۡoo顣Ү˹Dick KeyesڡȮxҼYfȮx߲Ȯ֮ŴȮxc҂Ȯx֮gK]бȻĂPϵoՓǷ f^ҊWֻ֪Ȯ@fκΕrطБԣ˵ĄәCͳɾ͡ɡ͡Ǳ󣬲ӷֱġȮxֻҼ\yıf

ŴȮxڲ̶ͬϓԼĂ͵ʄtԴ˞˜ʁҕͳЦg̓Ρݡ͹ȮxWɵǰ˹̩ᣨAntisthenesԪǰ445ǰ365K׵ČWǣfȮx˂׷ݵԪǰ4oĵҊWᡣҊWJˑԓȻȻҼСȻĵƽ_˵ĵòȻbǻݡѭҎءؔԷQҼlĹeĹҧˣҧѣ˽mȻҊWҲеӣKδ܌WWɡ˹Crates of ThebesӰĵӣҼغͶČWϢȮxߣ^ώġɢMXؔcIͬϵϣHipparchia of MaroneiaҼ^Ưؚ

S˹WɣStoicismd춴ˌWɴ֥ZZenosԪǰ336sǰ264Ӱ푣ȮxڹԪǰ3o^ҼΏd˹׺춿ƺ̵͈ͬ~׷^o_^˹WɰѲҕ˵뾳硣ѐǐfʹͲHHǁԃĵҊ@ǿ`ġ㣬ҼԳԼ@Լı֣Ҽ[`Ա־oҼ硣@ҼNoڬFеõMȡҿƺ[̡

[̺ͲаȮxĳɷ֣ѐǐˡƺ̵͈ľޟc澳еίȫƈ͵ͬҼ˼Băɂͬ档˹WɽȮxĻrֵ^ƾȻƁ혏ȻԵ˹W˳ɞҼNȮxԡʵĵ܌W˹WK׺ͰDӰ푣{¾֪RJĵОR،ĿĵО飬ԶxյО顣Ҫǣ˹Wɏ{ɵI˵ĵОx_ĄәC@SWҕ顰ġ^lܐȻҲЌWJ飬ڹԪǰ5oϣD˾ѽÄәCД˵О|ˌĵJRԪǰ4oϣDнFߐuߐu^ָġ

cŴȮxȣFȮxҪѽ͑׃ҼNԭtĒҼ߅̓ox͟ox@Ҳɞ鮔Ļ󼲵ĸԭ򡣬FȮxmȻĳNMFRsŗ˵ԳֻЄӡ粻׃øõďصױ^x˘춷е^^SαJ桢yúTˮ~BȡŴȮǡ[ʿʽСcͬFȮ󱊣ȮđBwB͸ճ˼SОԒZ֮УSrcķYϡں׃о߷Q˞@Fwġ볚ȮxmiasmIc cynicismƽӹcġҎȮxroutine cynicismЇضhY@NȮxwǟۡ롢چʺ͟oġ

ŴȮxѶ؄e棬ףFȮxtѶȫ棬ŴȮǘOٔ˵ʽFȮxtҼNձĻΑB˼ұ˵á˹صϿڡȮСҼYָFȮxҼNRΑBҼNcΡwܲɷֵırepresentationϵy^ϡK҅^˹ϣD_ֿȮxkynicismͬFǷNׅfġֿȮxcynicism

ȮxҪǿ͸ͬrsoͲκοϣκҼNСߡı涼춶؝˽ƺ_κҼN롢rֵ涼ܰlF_֡ԎӋΣU\ӢZ{Ǵo䡷@ЩȮx߶xģҼȮxߡֻО˽әCʹŻMsСo˽О^cĿܡ˹صϿ˵ĶxǣȮxǡڽ^ɵ˂YҼNձеĿ﷽ʽ^ްϮ_

ȮxҼNߵұoֶΣ^̫_^̫Į^̫Ă׃ʲᶼšԼ^ҼЩ΢popصĲڏԵęǰֻܣoҲִ͎Jŗ׃Լ\κϣ

FȮxе˂ǿ՚ҼȻ^ЧŴȮxߵסҕFpXؔᗉؔhx옷ˣS߀wˣ|혷ͽXğ׷ߡҼ˵wȮxĮo顢ϣġ֮⣬߀NȮxЙݡݡ֪RͽėlܷеġҼNWҸ·fġȮxcynicism of the powerљԡO˵ĬFǘOxڶNǿv͵ġjUȮxdecadent cynicismYXԺܡԡSv£ԷQЬF^ġˡHǟoƵؿv혷

Nǡ֪RȮxintellectual cynicism߶^ߵϵĽஔ˼RЌWߡڡҡҡӛߡýw˵wI֪RȮx߶ǘO֮ˣF[ҎtҼNܽ^⡢ѡJͬĽܡȾεĺRɿڡRΑBĳ߿wҼYQ@ӵĂ˞顰ȮwfȮw֪RΑBcF֮gľxǲÓ¼档˹صϿfԼҼf̹Ȼ֮

Ȯrcϣ

FȮxҼNµĵ̓oxҼNwļ[ȮxܙCءĿ˽؝șࡢ\_L춲XFcľx_ͻìܡǣĵ̓oxKܽ^棬ѵĠB£ԼҲ[ˣĿKܳɞҼNеµõ֪R

˹صϿҼӣRɿ˰ѡƹٷĻȮxQkynicismL\áS͡S̡Դ˅^eǷNġϺ푑yĻĬFȮxcynicIsmFȮx׽yߵڣ֪RΑBcFĲ࣬߀Ǖҳɡ@NȮxKֱӳַǵµǸǵ·յĵ¡Ȯǻ۵ģʽǰ\ֱɲ\ʽѵ®ɷʎʽ挍ЧeʽˣڬFȮxYֱcɡ\c̓Ρc䡢挍ce֮gK]Ќ|ą^eֻ^ҼҼϷøöѡRɿfIؔȮxߵķǣϷٍX䌍ǸЧĴٺ͔ؔRϣڡëX脡YfҼyб_Ҽyʲ᣿ͬӣǂbģٔXڌи[ΡЧČơȻˣα߀ҪҪ˙ࣿȮxYֻЃɷNˣ˺ͼٺˣٺ˱˸ģČ˸еá

Ȯxﱾ|ͱgą^eҼٷֱıҪcܣ׃ÌRΑBļy܉̩Ȼ֮̎Rɿˌ@ӵRΑBQ顰ٷRΑBָǷN˲ں٣˿ȥŵRΑBf˹xwԣ@ҼNԵĈԳ֣҂횲ϧκδrSֱ҂֪ĻMҰUϵY҂횲ϧκδrhĽyҼıκ˶ǂyRΑBÿ˶ȮxľxÿҲ֪e˲RΑBǣ@ӵıȻϧκδrؾS@Nı|󱻴ݚҼ˹_ʵ۱Ҽz졯@Ҽ@@ƶȾ͕߽⡣

Ҽz족ǌȮʽ[mfeĸf[mǣ]ʲ[mģferbfԒ@ҼN֪ܿ^fļ[׌W棬˶܅cУyε_ǺεģbxڽyΣ˶ֻ֪ǞԼ桪ˏԼęҼYЄӵıF錦FĳЩֵľܽ^JͬͲǣڽҶJҼz족ԵĬFУȮxχ׃yԴںͰlá@߷քeᘌԡƶȺ̓rֵďص׿ͷ񶨡

Ȯxǌˡʧȥĺϣԣ˵ҼкО涼ҼͲɸ˵ĄәC˸ԼкОġҮ˹f@NȮxK͖|W؄eձ飬˂رeԣL܉ƣorҴeԣeԶNӣǳأʹࡣˌ֮⣬˂ȮxѽɞڶԡԵďصʧǏČMӡӢʧ_ʼģĵòȻ͵fwͨ˟o؝̡_͂ơS˕ʹJ飬^ĐۡͬĶ^ǿնfo挍YĲ^̓˼룬ֻЏصܽX͙֧؝˽挍ı|

ȮxƶȡҲͬʧȥĺϣ@ҲǏČκ͹ĻÜ_ʼġlҲҊġƶȡlԿҊ\ƶȵκ͹ϰYġ١˂ڴƶȣ١ɞ؝Ĵ~ԂMƵƶȲaஅ¶ĕr򣬽^˱ƶȮaʧͲΡOٔ@rt֕Թƶȵķʽ@ƶqo@NqoδЧsҼYˑɺͷƶȵȮxNӡȻ]ƶȣȻеƶȱ|϶ǾSoٔğĻᣬ^ecơcOࡢxec픶಻^ǿ^Մȫ]Ќ|x

ˡ͡ƶȡȮxضcrֵȮxӰSĳɫrֵ񶨺ȡmrֵǃrֵȮxĳҊF@ҼNO˵ărֵՓ񶨲ͬrֵ֮gеxݺm̶ȵĲeԳ֣κ΃rֵֻ~ărֵȻǺ档Ȼˣκărֵԭt^˻_˵ĸeԡ

죬˂ڴЇθĸoǏăɂO׃ĿܺϣҼԺƶȌʧµҼԂ˻ĵƶȸĸoՓǈԳƶȃ߀ǵȣĸϣx_x͹κrֵҼ׌Ȯx߽҂ԡƶȺxrֵĺϣκ׃ĿҲͲʹڡ

ȮxҼN^^SğoĿʽϣărֵҲϣcȮx෴ϣҼN׃ķeO˼ʽԽyͣĕrҪϣԽҪȮxڂĻ϶ˡϣWHоWڸY¿ɭFredricksonڡxϣҼЏ{ϣЌ_҂ءȥֺ֑ͽ^Ļϣ׌҂Vľ׃øЄҲδġϣ˵ľ⣬ǰֳMԻͲ_ĕr򣬲؄eҪģҲ؄eйáϣҼNǰհ_˹ҼׁСf҂YЩƄ^Xгg˂ʧҲʧȥϣ

Wʩε£SnyderڡϣWҼָϣ횰֣ÿҪöx_ɡĂwҲx_eO_xЄӡҼǡĿˡgoalsʩεָϣҪĿˣĿ҂^XYҪFĿġͽYϣĿ˽춲ܺͿ϶F֮gĿ˶ϣĂˣеСlәC،Լf҂

ϣĵڶǡIwillpowerʩεfIϣ˼SI˂_Ŀ˺ÿ˵˼lá˂Ŀ˵Խ롢Խȫ棬IҲԽ@ͬҲĺIx_Ŀ˵֪R@x_º̓rֵ֪RҼӡ

ϣĵǡwaypowerҲ^XγӋЄӵ؈Dָϣ˼˂^ضl±^ҪĿ˺ͲҪĿˣҲ˂ϣĕr܉MøFhЌH춿ǼϣķcОҼӣҼN`practical ethicsϣО鶼whضlδ_ЄĿ˺xЄӵĲԡ

ЇȮxҼNŗ׃ϣ҄f혏ġĺSʽОЄwχȮxγҼZqλ\fġ̡Ͷࡰ˹̹Oz򞡱ĹƁ@Ȯxλ\Ҫ@CݵöࡣҰľҲҪr̓]˿ֵ֑ĴȥҼλ\^ҼNԶʽȮxҼN{m푪ΡΣC̎ʽ@ЩΣCǱ횽Qġ}ֻҪԼkͿ԰Ȼġ㡱@ӵYϕr˵׃ϣО`yúTǻۺ͡Ͳԭt

@ҼNs˽혏ġĬӱҎ^Ȯʽ˽혏ġpĬĄӱܡ@µsУRˏƣУ߽˷ˮҊ˼^ĹƲɱ׾CMУǳɞWߡڡҡˇgҡߺˆTͬcĺY@ҼNҶ֪@ÌҶк̎ԴҶ̹Ȼ֮[򡣵ǣKw߀ף@ǺȮ壬ጦl]к̎[