RΘO˻LwFxڮRȫcĻ_ʹȲl˷ѣ@N^бwFεĘO˻@ҼѱPI}ǣxˡΡ@NĻݵĶԪK춬FεĲDͬܕεĴ殐

ΘO䌦Ƶ

 

ξք݄ʎҼ]ĿĬFصΘOpolitical polarizationͻwF2016Ӣ@ÓW}ļҠhwFyxeİןữWҵڽȫ򻯡cyԼȺȆ}ϣFˇصҊy{͵硣Sμc֪RӞБn]ýwՓСΣCcیҊr

ՓУSW߶JxwNޣͻă֮Ҽ춑FԗlµĶԪx܉ԽyҼԭtЧذ݁KìFĶԲǰΘOyԾпͻƬFw܉պݼ{ЧԷQwƵΣCͲΣ o

ʹ˶ԣΘORҼ@Ҽ̵Փ}ҲҪČ`PԡԇDᘌǰҪΘOc춿@Ρ}Ph̽ӑĻcεPϵҼЩuՓ˼

ԭՓxd

 

ҼƪȕuָɮǰȲѵҪԭԴԃɷNY׃Ҽǽϵġȫ򻯡ÿ҃Ȳaȫ򻯵c씡ߣͬʧγˌȫ򻯵֧cđBȷѡĻϣȫ򻯌ı؂yrֵʽԼJͬˏҵě_y롢ֲxurl¾ք£@NĻ_׃øкͼJxĶԪĻxcȫxδЧػؑ@Ҽ_֮gaˌĻJͬ}Č֡

ě_ͻcĻVì໥˴˼m𣬘ΑBȷѵĻ@ЩΑBϵķɁѾãֻΌĝֻͨ^Ч΄ӆTcY@FFе໥ΑBȵġFactualization^ַ̣^ӄΑBȵķcOĶxehɄeΌF@2016yxԼKxĄ߉݋

oՓжˌյĿƷcLᅒģ҂yJгɿߣԸԵZ~f΄ӆTյķˑBxԼ׺yġ˃ԽՓA丂xаl]Ҫ΄ӆTܣSuՓѽ^ԔUͱĵՓ}ԣ҂PеĽc}춣պ܉VT׷NxWhite NationalismwͻcLƿءĻIࡱӆTͼYxγԼġĻΡxAÄ

ҼЩuՓҷָǘӣյġ׌ٴ΂󡱿̖Hĝ_~ǡ׌ٰMake American White AgainĴġ҂ҪZ҂ćҡWe want our country backҪZѽɵĻIġ׷NxWhite Nationalism@NS˿ӸࡱR܉ҏȼ@ƺ@ġ

˼ʷĽ̿ƕԼԒZУ߂xxyȱҼǷNԹͬѪ˷NZԞAJͬՓxҲoϚWޣǵʽģѪcءgZ⣬ԌŗlĹͬ\綨ģ@^ġx

1922꣬Ӣ˹DG. K. ChestertonָΨҼҼNŗla creedćң壩@ŗlڡԡԾн̗lʽWԵõWSeymore LipsetՓՓҲָǡҼµ塱ه춪صRΑBɡƽxxxͷɽ͢D@λ폊{̂yΌWҡҲŗlՓJ顰ԵͬJͬŗlrֵ^@ʹ׺ǪҼoġʹ˶ԣҼӢ׃áӢǲ˼hģܽ^ǂŗlĺͷģun-Americanɴ˿xrֵ^Ժҕf硱ǷN춷NصģԭՓx

͢Dڡ҂lҼЌWASP˵İ-d½̣yĻĺģܵVĠhҲ؄eָ{ĲWASP˷NĻyHϣ@Ҽи߶ȠhĚvʷǶȿġߡwԚWޣWĻڽĻϣ´ꑵSǚW޵ġͽܵڽ̉ʹҪҼ_źͰߵġ硱SĜ룬^Jͬ綨˵˼՝uУɞŷărֵ룬\@ЩձxՓvζǡˡ@xϣJͬġĻǻԭγɵġĻΡ@ˡɫx@Nɫ^ϚW޵޷棬ʧ䡰´ꑡľ|

 

҂˿fVTҼN춰˷NġԭՓxǌyıxǡġȻ2016ԣ]ЏصҲ|ˡՓԒյġĻΡɾͱH춡ΞΞĻyΞˡȆ}ĸUጏδKYxՓȻ{ԭՓķN@N׷NxδصᣬֻڡvʷMĺ_£߅sʼKݴl

ε;

ɻĆ}ǣVTձ˙cƽȃrֵxĻLռĻI࣬δֶܵR׷Nxҏȼ

@ж෽ԭ򡣾ɵČֶԣծɿӻӆTஔPIԌȫЩܴİ˹AӵVcNĻVY½ˣbɡyĻՓ

Ҽ棬ɱeλcʧҲҪʡУcɷŗOĻŬ춡ĻΡăAֵ˼͌`УĻݶԪ܌Ύ{oXĄͷΡԪĻxΡJΡ͡Ρ

@}ϣ炐ȁWRˡYMark LillaՓPӑՓ]Ŀ2016yxY᲻ܣYڡ~sr󡷰l£uxidentity liberalismʧɞ鮔걻xՓ¡SڴĵĻAϔUչa䣬ڽ8³ˡcδɣ֮ᡷҼ˼JumlVķch飨Ԃ飩Ҽɵ֪RӣYuҲҼȲc˼

YKĻԣJĶҼõ顱JՓҼЩeOxMxߵĵԣγɌٔ߅ȺwİcؑBȡε|FxՓΣoՓڵ϶ЃrֵڬFУxeεĸԶԣǘOǵġhIČ|MչڸȡQ춌wƵպӰͨ^MCɵμңƄӺ䌍ЩMxȡĿˣAӡN塢Ԅeȷ̎ݵȺwƽș档У@wӰֱӷʽAøNxe@ҪԒZ͑ԌVxfYJ飬VTĹͬԺ͈FYǏ{ȺwĪز׃PҪՓǡǡ@PI};

YεġSr_˹ͿψrڣǕrxλձxcƽԭt˹ĹݡԽrڵ\_ʼxΰlҼϵ͑׃ҼN҂ҡ͑׃ɴˡP]ĽcǃɷNJͬidentification҂ĹcJͬc҂ȲͬȺwJ֮ͬgPϵ˳@D˂DՄՓ˵ݣĵС󡪡ɎN塢ȡcԄeɫʲɵĪС顣u춲Σʹh˺ҕ䡰ĿˡԲͬ񱊾ۼҼ𣬞ҼͬĿ˶^YDҼN悀˻ġMĺԵġΡ

؄ee|ˡFBlack Lives Matter\ӣQ֮顰βȥFYĽ̿ƕʽĹ]зJ@Ҽ\ӵķeO棬ͨ^ʾͿh쌦˵ŰӆT֧߁K˵֪J飬@\ӛQҪ@NŰҼձԵָءᘌNvʷԼᘌ̷CKҲñƹԉƮhҪJc_Իڣ@NHϡo˹hԿɳ֮CY]xߣҼΆ݁_Ҽ}ǊՈČͬӵ顣ЩҼNƵˑԓʂñֵģҼN@οyxֵ÷ʡĽӖ֮ҼɵμlL팦ֵŪҼNΣ˃ԽՓ׷Nxcˌգ1960\I䂃]\ӵĻӼǘՄՓݡ\RVTĹ֮ͬ̎ʹ֪uЄӣʹ˸yϾSpؘ˜ʣҼNm춡˵ġҼNǽo˵ġJ飬Щ\IK]Ы@ȫĳɹ@KζʧˣҲCFбҪȡͬķ

⣬Y߀uՓ춵ԽеξޡSoxԡܽ^ׅfׅfҕѣ@ǆʧάFеĘIĸ]ǣԙzyӽo҂Ҫfˡе鶼Pԭt}ʹЩ_ˣҲͬҪԭtҪܾSo@ԭtrֵ^ҼzϿpƴDеƬKˣǷN^ׅfķʽ硰ҪÿҼжͬ⣨҂ʲҕNxxeȫȡģ顰УOҼ^ߵġ춞A֧ߺxeҪġͬ˜ԚԵġ

Yġδɡ􆾏ε;;֪ҼNΣ@ND׃Ҫġɡǰмȡ򞣺UչxεĻA棬VTйԵwˡ{ձƽcəĹݣKҕ^PеĆ}|ȡڽ̵Ļh}УΑǡķִƽеؑYĵˌδεĽONԡƶ΃\ΡfäĿұ_݃ȺݡKᳫУ@չ_@ȻĺՓּԡΡȡʧΡJαSޣԳJ@ɃHеϣ;



Yu˼Nͬ殐ȡ򣬏{xy춹ͬձrֵݼ{ԣn̈춲οܕԚxĸ􆾵ĹΣͬrP]ƽȵəĹݣԼ춈FYͷeOεĹ؟ΣHϽYxcxĹ^ȻεK·f@1990ՓӑՓh}YS֪еďshرyՓ}ҪάFxĲչ_Փ֧εՓɌ˲M֮ͶΣǡǡyĹ^Cķ˼cСYǾб؃Aɣֻǽմx@@ҼCcɰly

ҿc֮gą^eΌ`еĲͬȡЧxģ@ҲYҪؕI֮Ҽ@ȻĄօs׶ˡ҂бҪc֮gϵKܵĻֵ֧Pϵ1990WgP춶ԪĻxκεӑՓУΡ}K]ȫȱϯǱͽ綨@ڼMČWՓҲˡ

ՓҲīƣChantal MouffeҼNMķ˂yx^citizenship-as-rightsJ{˙ăԵĲUʹČ̓ݣСҎԡPѶ롰˽˵I򡱣ʹʧ䂐Sȣ͑顰xգHHP]ȶ֮gׅfx^νYǹR˥͹Єӵηs@ӵġO񡱟oγɼMҪˡīƁK]зŗεĸΑeȫDxƶȿ܃չ_MYʧȥԡAwݵėl£ҪҼNµwݣ񡱄tȡx

īUĹ݁Kxs˵ġݡlegal statusҲكHHзɵıoӵęߣҼN춹ͬPѡЄӵġZҼɹP_ҎԭtݡMZǡƽȡԭt@ǌFwZ΃rֵҼ鼤MUጣ伤M춣ҪеI򶼱횽@Ҽԭtġzyκ֧ԵĿPϵܻܵͨ^@ҼԭtZJͬcRNݣŮԡˡˡͬԑߺBxߵȵȣYͲٻP˼MĹͨԣγҼlxϵģȃr朡chain of equivalenceĶˡ҂MĹڴˣ݁KǬFɵģǡͨ^PѵJͬО@ݡɞҼζJҎtęԣԴˁָДЄӡڸN\ӵҪҼNwԵݣʹNԵYˡ

īļMԇDµĹθѸNֲ\ӼYγVˣĶȡMăݵλc֮gϵcͬr@NµĹȻYָxeҪ@V֧֣ȴwݵĻȺw֧֣ἤMĹκԌF@NĿˣīҼ؞hδɵģضǡ֮gĸԛ_ͻagonistic conflict between adversariesmȻ@^e춡֮gČԛ_ͻantagonistic conflict between enemiesȺw֮gě_ͻǺcFY@Nεīƺođ߸ؿ]ΘOĆ}@ԻSǼMвɱĬF

ꇠIУѹʵՓҰ˹Iris M. YoungǶԪĻxcՓI1989lҪՓġcȺwԹ^СУˡԹݡdifferentiated citizenshipĸָǷNĳԽȺwĹ^ǲxģڬFĳЩȺwؙ࣬ȺwsܵƣƵʽ߅oBĻۇxԼc}_@ҼУԳ鹫˂_صĚwPϵͽɼ{ҼNձ^Ǿֻӏؙࡣؙߵ^cڽyҼĹռ֧λȺw^cs߅]аlԙࡣ

ˣ׷ƽΣҪ҂JȺwJ挦Ĳ̎󡣌ĻϱųȺwᘌ^еĲ̎ṩЧƶֶΣQҪƽȳJƽȴĆ}ΣᘌģZԺ׵ȷģĻṩЧ֧߁M@Щ󡣶Pֻڿ]Ⱥwr²ſγɺ͌ʩ

Թ݌񡱽綨cձԣcĹͬԣJ飬FԹDǌwcҼԣcͬ|ԣ@ʹҼЩȺwų̎춲֮أʹʽƽȵĹݡ׌ÿɆT@ƽȵcǹεĿˣஔՓ_@NĿ˵ķʽҪ҂JҕȺwҕĨȥ@NġҼҕͬʡ򡰟oex@ҼĿˡ춡Թݡucqo^ஔ־öӑՓҼЩҶδQĆ}ҲlF˲c֮ͬgļݿܡ

빫cε{Փ

 

κĽ;SoҪĳN޶ȵϡʹɆTĹͬĻɺҎtyهɂҪأҼ̓rֵ^ͬ|߶ҼԣҼǡȻġЉԵģݵȼY@ɷNҪڬFԗl¶ʧȥЧԡڬF^У߶ȵԴMʽĶӻҲ̓rֵ^ĶԪͬ|Աg߽⡣ԪxɞFcͬrFƽxę^˂ٽ܂yСġȼYƽȶӻɆT֮g@ǬFRy}

ڎׂoĬFvʷlչУƶȣԭtԇDͬrQɂ}ձxechƽxVĻԣԑϵĹɑcʽĶԪ}ҲfFξԣDȱͬ|ԺȼYėl£ԱMܵ͵ćҏƌFΑBc֮gĺĶɶݵ@NУcĻ֮gďɆT֮gĸN硪PڽKOĿˣ룬ԼƵ^ȵĻhܱصs܉ͨ^޶߅硢ͨ^ԒԼՄׅfȷʽc⣬Kλԭt}_ɡدBRĶFĳNͶͬKͬ殐@xՓS

ȻĻ`ξSȣcĻĶNVĶӻĻҲͿ܌η硣ˣxǕ挦Ҽ]֮ȥ[ĻԌԵΑBlͿͻƱ޶߅ιR߽⣬KD׃صΌķ{ԵΣCǰ΄ʎҼ̶ĻΌס挦@NΣC҂бҪ˼xĝ̽ӑǷ܉ԼԿ܁푪@N

λUУxġͬ殐Ա顰֮ͬĻ݆֮}ԣÿ˿ܾжNݣܚwٶNȺwxϹͬĹ݃Ⱥwݣ@N˼·wF_˹ݵą^֮У鹫ġݡpublic identityԼ˽˂wġǹݡnonpublic identityǣIc˽IĽȻxKԇDȫÓx˽I򣨰˚wٵĈFwȺHHڹI֮УSrǲܵĺͲġ@Nx⵽ˏıصȺxMՓСάFǣ_˹ǹݡԡλƳFΣCNݾЏҵV󣬁KSλСRˡYġΡHԇDԹZݣҼ̶c_˹xҼµģҲ͕_˹ܵĸNuKͬӵ

DͬĹƺԉεġ殐rJοܕ{εĹ҂ڹc֮gҼǴ˼˵x᣿ߣ҂οܑ@֮gľo_ͻ挦@ҼyĆ}҇LԇҼЩС{Փreconciliationȡĳ˼ׂ档

ȣ@N{Փ춰lc֮gļԡĿǰɷN֮gď͹@r£҂пܺҕݵҼ档ČλՓҵĺu҂ԿoՓīƵļMՓ߀ǗĲԹՓ]зŗǈԳ˹@ҼԼƽȺɵҎԭtīƵġMּʹxθֵ؃FZԏ{KҲǡǡƽغ͌ԭtJRcҎԭtϵҼԻԣܴ_ҼNµܣεČ`пܣֵأɺ{Ƿŗζչ_@ͬrҲζп܌V_鹫εҼ֡ī{ڸMȺw֮gxϵġȃr朡N@NܡڲĲĿˣ磬xؚAԼꡢ˺ͬԑٵ@Щܵƺ̎ȺwԡࡱǞͨ^⌦˷ܵƵ̎K@ƽȌ@NҪȫпڹεҕҰбܣҕ顰ͨҼҪ֮·ę֮ӋԇDȡ@ЩƣĶ@NıҪԡο{@NεV󣬌𲽜pفKK@ЩҪ׌@NUmû

Σ{Փ،ԭtJRx^֮ȱݺ;޵ͬr@N{ՓxġƽȡӼ{ݲҪ󣬾ܽ^ݡвҕͬȵcϷԡ@ζڃɂ挦NͬĲԲČ

ҼMκεՓHϹܻͬĬJҎԭtڿܵr£^ecĲV󡣱磬@أĳNĻбŮԸYꎵг򌦃ͯıҎӖʽ@NȺwV`˹ҎҪ󣬲ԶԪĻɱҕ鲻ϷĲҪīƱҲOʽĶԪxκνҎ˜ʵĿܡʹ҂ԪԵĳJ춌ص׵Įcص׵ğoɅ^֣˜ʱ횴ڣжʲǿSĶʲ᲻ǡ

ڶ،ҲҪڼcϷĲVУڿܵr½ҼNȺwݵҪҪڌȺwݵҪԼwҪƽ⿼urKҪ󶼾еͬăԡMĳNҪrpʧȺwԼYԴĴr磬P춡DԄe@ҼȺw}ĠhУҪԃuСȻԵĲǸ߶ZهД࣬yKǲܵġ،ԭtζĳNxԵų⣬ЩĮҕˡԹεҼ挦Įҕ͉ҪqoɣͬrҼ棬Jκο󼰵xҲoصҕcơ

@N{Փ{ڌ`бM܌VZԡDg鹫εZԻZԡ磬F̖Č顰FͬˡǷ܉c֮goܵϵأеDgГpʧΌ`ҪĬFxĽǶʧ⡣@NҪεČ`߼ȺwԣгxDͬԵҕĶչ_˼ĕr̡RˡYSȱֵͬ⣬FβuֵJ挦ɴhľWվ^ȣhĿͻҼ顶dԭtļʮҼVP]Ά}hľWվҲƵԭtֻж_ʮ߂ͬȺwľWվ朽ӣǷքeԲͬV@NԷxV@ȱԺ͏VĸhεĲԶʧġȻΟos鹫Σ˲܌VЧDg鹫εZԣȻܡDg鹫܉ZԡH@NŬǿģҲǿɞġ

@N{ՓҲζxUǷNĻԪϡ⣬ɷQ֮顰ĻosιR^cJιR_ȫҪ|Ӻ͸׃NӵĻȺw͂˵ĻԲֻǿġֵᳫ͹ĄġĻMԱǧ˰ّBĲ@KK_ɵدBR@NĻosιR^cՓe`ģ䌍`˓nġدBRKǽ춸N֮gɰlĹ֮ͬ̎ͬĻ^໥دBĲҎԭtxϿǟoPoҪģҪ_ɹRҎԭtc棬˴˵ĽǡǡyԳFˣ_˹xҪͬȫԌWfŷҪĸ׃¶λ{ͿԼȫ@п܌εxԭt_ɹR@Ҳ{ĻcԡҪԵľ֮ҼˣǡxهĳNĻAҪڸNĻ֮gҼNĻ@ֻǰݺظNĻrֵʽĲͬrҲҪҼ̶ȵĻͬҪNȺc˵ĻVڌ`ܵs{εԽ\ЄmĻl